First record I ever got was the Decca 45 RPM She Loves You by The Beatles. I still have the record but it is too scratched and cracked to play. I do have a digital version that I still listen to.
My first full-length album was Chubby Checker's Beach Party. I haven't listened to it in years, but now that you've brought up the topic, I think I'll take it out of mothballs.